Social Inclusion
Programmes that targeted women deliberately (Golden Line, LISEC, Coffee Resilience in Kenya) opened new roles, membership and earning opportunities, but baselines show deep gaps in land, income and decision-making, and women still carry most of the labour.
Key evidence
- Golden Line: 14 Tanzanian mines now include women in management, and 73% of women reported positive changes in household financial decision-making; but women remained largely in lower-paid roles. The Golden Line programme · Endline · 2020
- In Kenya, women's membership of coffee cooperatives rose from 18% (2017) to 37% (2022) and youth in cooperative leadership from 27% to 48%; women's membership fell slightly in Uganda and Tanzania, and women still do over 80% of labour such as weeding. PFC · Endline · 2022
- LISEC supported 2,876 unemployed youth (1,889 female); about 69% of Youth Leadership Programme graduates found jobs, and 517 women joined 22 VSLAs. LISEC · Endline · 2024
- In OCDDP, women deciding on dairy sales rose from 3.6% to 44.1% of households, while men became more dominant in buying agricultural inputs (5.2% to 37.1%). OCDDP · Endline · 2021
- In TRACE Kenya, women made up 25.5% of training participants, 25% of men but only 13% of women earned in the first carbon auction, and 166 of 410 respondents said they do not share coffee benefits with spouse or children. TRACE Kenya · Endline · 2025
- Coffee baselines show large gaps: Kenyan women held 0.61 acres against 1.86 for men; in Tanzania men own about 95% of coffee farms while women and youth supply up to 75% of manual labour. P2P · BaselineP2P · Baseline
- Physical intimate partner violence in the past 12 months was reported by 26.9% of women in Buvuma and 22.4% in Mayuge, and in Mukono only 19.4% of survivors reported it. NOPP · BaselineNOPP · Baseline
- Women's participation in FOSEK training was low (an estimated 20–30%), and PfC had no gender-specific KPIs or monitoring. FOSEK · Endline · 2021Practice for Change programme (PfC), excluding NI-SCOPS projects · Endline · 2020
In figures
Earlier measurement Later measurement
Women's coffee cooperative membership, Kenya
Women's coffee cooperative membership, Kenya
2017: 18 → 2022: 37 % of members or households
18 → 372017: 18 → 2022: 37 % of members or households
Youth in coffee cooperative leadership, Kenya
Youth in coffee cooperative leadership, Kenya
2017: 27 → 2022: 48 % of members or households
27 → 482017: 27 → 2022: 48 % of members or households
Youth coffee cooperative membership, Kenya
Youth coffee cooperative membership, Kenya
2017: 9 → 2022: 16 % of members or households
9 → 162017: 9 → 2022: 16 % of members or households
Women deciding on dairy sales, OCDDP Ethiopia
Women deciding on dairy sales, OCDDP Ethiopia
Baseline: 3.6 → Endline 2021: 44.1 % of members or households
3.6 → 44.1Baseline: 3.6 → Endline 2021: 44.1 % of members or households
Women deciding on household purchases, OCDDP Ethiopia
Women deciding on household purchases, OCDDP Ethiopia
Baseline: 2.8 → Endline 2021: 36.3 % of members or households
2.8 → 36.3Baseline: 2.8 → Endline 2021: 36.3 % of members or households
VSLA women reporting economic independence, LISEC Ethiopia
VSLA women reporting economic independence, LISEC Ethiopia
Baseline: 30 → Endline 2024: 68 % of members or households
30 → 68Baseline: 30 → Endline 2024: 68 % of members or households
Each row is a different measure in its own population; rows show direction of change, not a ranking.
PFC · Endline · 2022OCDDP · Endline · 2021LISEC · Endline · 2024
Data table
| Item | Earlier | Later |
|---|---|---|
| Women's coffee cooperative membership, Kenya | 18 (2017) | 37 (2022) |
| Youth in coffee cooperative leadership, Kenya | 27 (2017) | 48 (2022) |
| Youth coffee cooperative membership, Kenya | 9 (2017) | 16 (2022) |
| Women deciding on dairy sales, OCDDP Ethiopia | 3.6 (Baseline) | 44.1 (Endline 2021) |
| Women deciding on household purchases, OCDDP Ethiopia | 2.8 (Baseline) | 36.3 (Endline 2021) |
| VSLA women reporting economic independence, LISEC Ethiopia | 30 (Baseline) | 68 (Endline 2024) |
Change over time
Golden Line (women in gold-mining communities) Tanzania
- Baseline 2017Only 25% of community women said women always have the same earning opportunities as men.
- Midline 2019Most project mines had women in management; 64% reported positive changes in household financial decision-making.
- Endline 202014 mines include women in management and 73% reported positive changes in decision-making, but only 7% of women had changed jobs.
LISEC (leather sector) Ethiopia
- Midline 2022The 4-day youth training lacked employability content such as CV writing and job search.
- Endline 2024About 69% of YLP graduates obtained jobs, and 68% of VSLA women reported economic independence (30% at baseline).
What works
- Role models, such as the first women in mine management, changed perceptions of what women can do. Golden Line Programme · Midline
- Involving men through gender discussion series (EMAP) was highly appreciated, though reaching men beyond those already willing is slow. Golden Line Programme · Midline
- Savings-group models (EA$E, VSLAs) need few external inputs and are likely to last. The Golden Line programme · Endline · 2020LISEC · Endline · 2024
- Intentional targeting, such as flexible training schedules and dedicated gender partnerships, improved inclusion. TRACE Kenya · Endline · 2025Bottom Up · Endline · 2023
What holds results back
- Women rarely own land or hold titles, which limits their decision-making and access to finance. TRACE Kenya · Endline · 2025P2P · BaselineRS! · Baseline · 2025
- Efforts to raise women's participation sometimes added labour-intensive work to their load. PFC · Endline · 2022
- Women deciding on a sale does not mean they benefit equally from the income. OCDDP · Endline · 2021
- Rising incomes were sometimes accompanied by gender-based violence. Golden Line Programme · Midline
Recommendations for programming
- Give gender dedicated staff, budget and indicators, including women and youth participation indicators in results frameworks. FOSEK · Endline · 2021Practice for Change programme (PfC), excluding NI-SCOPS projects · Endline · 2020PACE · Midline
- Promote joint membership of farmer organisations and leadership rules such as the two-thirds gender rule. RS! · Baseline · 2025P2P · Baseline
- Set up grievance mechanisms so women can report safety and sexual harassment problems at work sites. Golden Line Programme · MidlineThe Golden Line programme · Endline · 2020
- Pair economic empowerment with GBV prevention and response. Golden Line Programme · MidlineNOPP · Baseline
- Do a deeper gender analysis (roles, land and asset rights) before and during implementation. PFC · Endline · 2022
Evidence gaps & caveats
- GBV and sensitive topics are likely under-reported in surveys.
- Youth outcomes are rarely measured separately from women's outcomes.
- Disability inclusion is almost never measured.
Source studies (17)
- National Oil Palm Project Baseline Study Report (Phase I: Kalangala, Buvuma and Mayuge Hubs)Uganda · Baseline
- Mid Term Evaluation Report for Passport to Coffee Export (PACE) Project, TanzaniaTanzania · Midline
- Quantitative baseline report Going for Gold: Tanzania & Ghana (revised version)Regional (ECA) · Baseline
- Mid-term Evaluation Report for LISEC-Green: An OECD-DAC Evaluation of the Leather Initiative for Sustainable Employment and Job Creation (LISEC) Green Jobs ProjectEthiopia · Midline
- National Oil Palm Project Baseline Study Report: Masaka and Mukono HubsUganda · Baseline
- Baseline Assessment for the Coffee Project under the Pathways to Prosperity Program Tanzania: Final Baseline ReportTanzania · Baseline
- Golden Line Programme Midterm Review Final ReportRegional (ECA) · Midline
- Baseline Assessment for the Coffee Project under the Pathways to Prosperity Program - Kenya: Final Baseline ReportKenya · Baseline
- Reclaim Sustainability! Programme Baseline Report – Coffee Program, Uganda and KenyaRegional (ECA) · Baseline · Jan 2021 – Dec 2025
- Evaluation Report: Endline Survey – The Traceable Organic Coffee from Kenya ProjectKenya · Endline · Jan 2020 – Mar 2025
- Final Evaluation for the Leather Initiative for Sustainable Employment Creation (LISEC) in Oromia Regional State, East Shewa Zone, Modjo Town, EthiopiaEthiopia · Endline · Jan 2021 – Apr 2024
- End-term Evaluation of Bottom Up Project in EthiopiaEthiopia · Endline · Apr 2019 – Mar 2023
- Evaluation Report: Scaling Investment for the Resilience of East Africa Coffee Producers Program (Tanzania, Kenya and Uganda)Regional (ECA) · Endline · Jan 2018 – Dec 2022
- FOSEK End-line Evaluation Final Report 2021Regional (ECA) · Endline · Sept 2013 – Dec 2021
- Oromia Coffee and Dairy Development Project (OCDDP): Final Report, End-line Evaluation StudyEthiopia · Endline · Jul 2016 – Apr 2021
- The Golden Line Programme End Term Evaluation Final ReportTanzania · Endline · Jan 2016 – Dec 2020
- Evaluation of Solidaridad Practice for Change programme (PfC): Final reportRegional (ECA) · Endline · Jan 2016 – Dec 2020
