Access to Finance
Formal credit reaches few farmers even where information is available, while savings groups (VSLAs, EA$E, community microfinance groups) are the finance channel that works and lasts; engagement with financial institutions largely failed.
Key evidence
- In the Coffee Resilience programme, over 70% of farmers had easy access to information on agricultural finance, but fewer than 40% in Uganda and fewer than 30% in Kenya and Tanzania took credit, linked to difficult loan terms and a lack of coffee-specific products. PFC · Endline · 2022
- In CROSL, 13.9% of households had obtained an agricultural loan in two years and 54.6% considered interest rates excessively high, although 71.2% belonged to savings and credit cooperatives. CROSL · Baseline · 2028
- 80% of Bungoma maize farmers had not accessed credit in the past year; 23% of H4G farmers had accessed agricultural credit at baseline. CSV · BaselineH4G · Baseline
- In Tanzanian gold-mining communities, 77% of women reported no access to credit; in Buvuma, 20% had a bank or microfinance account (24.3% of men, 11.0% of women). GfG · BaselineNOPP · Baseline
- PACE's 75 community microfinance groups held shares of TZS 461.6 million, and 46% of households reported access to financial services. PACE · Midline
- LISEC established 22 VSLAs with 517 women, and 68% of them reported economic independence at endline against 30% at baseline. LISEC · Endline · 2024
- FOSEK had essentially no financial services, and GTI did not achieve its access-to-finance target through two financial institutions; Golden Line's engagement with financial institutions was limited. FOSEK · Endline · 2021GTI · Endline · 2021The Golden Line programme · Endline · 2020
In figures
Agricultural loan in past 2 years, CROSL Ethiopia
Agricultural loan in past 2 years, CROSL Ethiopia
13.9 % of farmers or women
13.913.9 % of farmers or women
Accessed credit in past year, maize farmers Bungoma
Accessed credit in past year, maize farmers Bungoma
20 % of farmers or women
2020 % of farmers or women
Accessed agricultural credit, H4G horticulture farmers
Accessed agricultural credit, H4G horticulture farmers
23 % of farmers or women
2323 % of farmers or women
Access to credit, women in Tanzanian gold communities
Access to credit, women in Tanzanian gold communities
23 % of farmers or women
2323 % of farmers or women
Bungoma and Tanzania figures are 100% minus the share reporting no credit access. Questions and recall periods differ by study.
CROSL · Baseline · 2028CSV · BaselineH4G · BaselineGfG · Baseline
Data table
| Item | % of farmers or women |
|---|---|
| Agricultural loan in past 2 years, CROSL Ethiopia | 13.9 |
| Accessed credit in past year, maize farmers Bungoma | 20 |
| Accessed agricultural credit, H4G horticulture farmers | 23 |
| Access to credit, women in Tanzanian gold communities | 23 |
Change over time
Golden Line (women in gold-mining communities) Tanzania
- Baseline 201777% of community women had no access to credit; 11.3% had a bank or savings-group account.
- Endline 2020EA$E savings groups judged likely to last because they need few external inputs; trust in groups stayed high.
LISEC (leather sector) Ethiopia
- Midline 2022No local institution identified to keep forming VSLA groups after the project.
- Endline 202422 VSLAs with 517 women (target 20); 68% of members reported economic independence.
What works
- Savings-group models need few external inputs and keep running after support is reduced. The Golden Line programme · Endline · 2020LISEC · Endline · 2024
- Community microfinance groups mobilised substantial member savings and helped enterprises open bank accounts. PACE · Midline
What holds results back
- Loan terms and products do not fit farming cash flows, and interest rates are considered too high. PFC · Endline · 2022CROSL · Baseline · 2028
- Delayed disbursement: 88% of Tanzanian P2P farmers reporting credit problems cited it. P2P · Baseline
- Collateral requirements and lack of land titles exclude women and youth. P2P · BaselineTRACE Kenya · Endline · 2025
- Financial institutions were not engaged as partners from the start. FOSEK · Endline · 2021GTI · Endline · 2021
Recommendations for programming
- Develop coffee- and crop-specific credit products. RS! · Thematic studyPFC · Endline · 2022
- Turn one-off seed funds into revolving funds managed through cooperative offices or financial institutions. PACE · MidlineTRACE Kenya · Endline · 2025
- Link mature VSLAs to credit and help them grow into MSMEs or formal cooperatives. LISEC · Endline · 2024NOPP · BaselineCROSL · Baseline · 2028
- Include financial institutions as partners from design, and use public-private partnerships to de-risk lending. FOSEK · Endline · 2021CROSL · Baseline · 2028
Evidence gaps & caveats
- Most finance data come from baselines; loan use, repayment and outcomes are rarely tracked at endline.
- Savings-group impacts are self-reported and not compared with non-members.
Source studies (16)
- Mid Term Evaluation Report for Passport to Coffee Export (PACE) Project, TanzaniaTanzania · Midline
- Mid-term Evaluation Report for LISEC-Green: An OECD-DAC Evaluation of the Leather Initiative for Sustainable Employment and Job Creation (LISEC) Green Jobs ProjectEthiopia · Midline
- Fair Value Distribution Analysis in the Coffee Sector: A Research to Advocate for Policy Changes in Kenya and UgandaRegional (ECA) · Thematic study
- Baseline Survey for the Creating Shared Value in the Maize Value Chain Project for Solidaridad East and Central AfricaKenya · Baseline
- Baseline Assessment for the Coffee Project under the Pathways to Prosperity Program Tanzania: Final Baseline ReportTanzania · Baseline
- Baseline Assessment for the Coffee Project under the Pathways to Prosperity Program - Kenya: Final Baseline ReportKenya · Baseline
- National Oil Palm Project Baseline Study Report (Phase I: Kalangala, Buvuma and Mayuge Hubs)Uganda · Baseline
- Baseline Study for the Horticulture for Growth (H4G) Project: Promoting Horticulture Enterprise Development in KenyaKenya · Baseline
- Quantitative baseline report Going for Gold: Tanzania & Ghana (revised version)Regional (ECA) · Baseline
- Baseline Evaluation for Climate Resilient Opportunities for Sustainable Livelihoods Project in Minjar Shenkora District, Amhara Regional State, Ethiopia (July 2025 - June 2028)Ethiopia · Baseline · Jul 2025 – Jun 2028
- Evaluation Report: Endline Survey – The Traceable Organic Coffee from Kenya ProjectKenya · Endline · Jan 2020 – Mar 2025
- Final Evaluation for the Leather Initiative for Sustainable Employment Creation (LISEC) in Oromia Regional State, East Shewa Zone, Modjo Town, EthiopiaEthiopia · Endline · Jan 2021 – Apr 2024
- Evaluation Report: Scaling Investment for the Resilience of East Africa Coffee Producers Program (Tanzania, Kenya and Uganda)Regional (ECA) · Endline · Jan 2018 – Dec 2022
- End Line Evaluation for Green Tanning Initiative (GTI) project in EthiopiaEthiopia · Endline · Jan 2018 – Dec 2021
- FOSEK End-line Evaluation Final Report 2021Regional (ECA) · Endline · Sept 2013 – Dec 2021
- The Golden Line Programme End Term Evaluation Final ReportTanzania · Endline · Jan 2016 – Dec 2020
